OnlyRecipe vs Paprika: Complete Comparison Guide 2025
Choosing between OnlyRecipe and Paprika Recipe Manager? Here's everything you need to know about features, pricing, and which app is right for you.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | OnlyRecipe | Paprika |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $2.99/mo or $24.99/yr (AI: $3.99/mo or $34.99/yr) | $4.99 per platform (one-time purchase) |
| AI Features | ✓ Advanced AI | ✗ None |
| Social Media Import | ✓ TikTok, YouTube, Instagram | ✗ Not supported |
| Screenshot Import | ✓ AI-powered | ✗ Not supported |
| Handwritten Recipes | ✓ AI recognition | ✗ Not supported |
| Website Import | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Meal Planning | ✓ AI-powered | ✓ Calendar-based |
| Grocery Lists | ✓ Smart lists | ✓ Aisle sorting |
| Cloud Sync | ✓ Included | ✓ Free |
| Offline Access | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Cross-Platform | Single subscription | Separate purchase per platform |
| Free Version | 20 recipes, 3 AI imports/day | 50 recipes, no sync |
The Bottom Line
Choose OnlyRecipe if: You want modern AI features like importing recipes from TikTok, YouTube, Instagram videos, screenshots, or handwritten recipes. OnlyRecipe is perfect for the 2025 cook who discovers recipes on social media.
Choose Paprika if: You prefer a one-time purchase model and primarily save recipes from traditional websites. Paprika is a solid, established choice for basic recipe management.
Detailed Feature Comparison
📥 Recipe Import & Management
OnlyRecipe
- Social Media Import: Import directly from TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, and Facebook videos using AI
- Screenshot Import: Take a screenshot of any recipe and import it with AI recognition
- Handwritten Recipes: Digitize grandma's handwritten recipes with AI
- Website Import: One-tap import from any recipe website
- In-App Browser: Browse and save without leaving the app
Paprika
- Website Import: Built-in browser and bookmarklet for saving recipes
- Manual Entry: Add your own recipes
- No AI Features: No social media, screenshot, or handwritten recipe support
🏆 Winner: OnlyRecipe
OnlyRecipe's AI-powered import features are game-changing for modern cooks who discover recipes on social media. Paprika is limited to traditional website imports.
🤖 AI & Smart Features
OnlyRecipe
- AI-powered video recipe extraction
- AI meal planning suggestions
- Automatic nutritional analysis
- Smart ingredient recognition from images
- AI-powered recipe organization
Paprika
- No AI features
- Manual organization and categorization
- Timer detection in recipe directions
🏆 Winner: OnlyRecipe
Paprika was built before the AI revolution. OnlyRecipe brings modern AI capabilities that save time and enhance your cooking experience.
💰 Pricing Comparison
OnlyRecipe
- Free: 20 recipes, 3 AI imports/day, basic features
- Premium: $2.99/month or $24.99/year - unlimited recipes, all features
- AI Premium: $3.99/month or $34.99/year - unlimited AI imports
- Single subscription works across all devices
Paprika
- iOS/Android: $4.99 (one-time, per platform)
- Mac: $19.99 (one-time)
- Windows: $14.99 (one-time)
- Free version: 50 recipes, no cloud sync
- Total cost for all platforms: ~$40-45
🏆 Winner: Depends on your needs
If you only use one device, Paprika's one-time purchase ($4.99) is cheaper long-term. But if you use multiple platforms, OnlyRecipe's single subscription ($24.99/year) is more economical and includes modern AI features Paprika doesn't offer.
📱 User Experience
OnlyRecipe
- Modern, clean interface built for 2025
- Intuitive navigation and search
- Fast recipe imports with AI
- Web app available (beta)
- Regular updates with new features
Paprika
- Established, familiar interface
- Reliable and stable
- Offline-first design
- Customizable categories and organization
- Family sharing on iOS (up to 5 devices)
🏆 Winner: Tie
Both apps offer excellent user experiences. Paprika is tried-and-true, while OnlyRecipe offers a more modern interface with cutting-edge features.
Pros & Cons
OnlyRecipe Pros
- ✓ AI-powered social media imports
- ✓ Screenshot & handwritten recipe support
- ✓ Modern AI features
- ✓ Single subscription for all platforms
- ✓ Generous free tier
- ✓ Regular updates and new features
OnlyRecipe Cons
- ✗ Subscription model (not one-time purchase)
- ✗ Newer app (less established than Paprika)
- ✗ Web app still in beta
Paprika Pros
- ✓ One-time purchase (no subscription)
- ✓ Established and reliable
- ✓ Excellent offline support
- ✓ Pantry management feature
- ✓ Free cloud sync included
- ✓ Family sharing on iOS
Paprika Cons
- ✗ No AI features
- ✗ No social media import
- ✗ No screenshot/handwritten support
- ✗ Separate purchase per platform ($40+ total)
- ✗ Limited to website imports
Who Should Choose Which App?
Choose Paprika if you:
- • Prefer one-time purchases over subscriptions
- • Only use one device (iOS or Android)
- • Primarily save recipes from traditional websites
- • Don't need AI features
- • Want pantry management features
- • Value offline-first design
Choose OnlyRecipe if you:
- • Discover recipes on TikTok, YouTube, or Instagram
- • Want to import from screenshots or handwritten recipes
- • Use multiple devices (phone, tablet, computer)
- • Want modern AI-powered features
- • Prefer a single subscription for all platforms
- • Want the latest technology and regular updates
Switching from Paprika to OnlyRecipe
Making the switch is straightforward:
- Export from Paprika: Use Paprika's export feature to save your recipes
- Download OnlyRecipe: Get the app from the App Store or Google Play
- Start Fresh or Import: You can manually re-import recipes from their original sources (OnlyRecipe makes this fast with one-tap import) or start building your new collection
- Try AI Features: Import your first recipe from a TikTok video or screenshot to experience the difference
💡 Pro Tip
Start with OnlyRecipe's free plan to test it alongside Paprika. You get 20 recipe saves and 3 AI imports per day—enough to evaluate if it's right for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can OnlyRecipe import my Paprika recipes?
Currently, there's no direct import from Paprika. However, since most recipes originally came from websites, you can quickly re-import them using OnlyRecipe's one-tap website import feature.
Is OnlyRecipe really better than Paprika?
"Better" depends on your needs. OnlyRecipe excels with AI features and social media imports, making it ideal for modern cooks. Paprika is excellent for traditional recipe management with a one-time purchase model. Both are great apps serving different user preferences.
Does OnlyRecipe work offline like Paprika?
Yes! OnlyRecipe stores your recipes locally, so you can access them offline. The main difference is that AI features (like importing from videos) require an internet connection.
Which app is cheaper in the long run?
For a single device, Paprika ($4.99 one-time) is cheaper. For multiple platforms, OnlyRecipe ($24.99/year) is more economical than buying Paprika for iOS ($4.99), Mac ($19.99), and Android ($4.99) separately (~$30-45 total).
Can I try OnlyRecipe before paying?
Absolutely! OnlyRecipe offers a generous free plan with 20 recipe saves and 3 AI imports per day. This lets you fully test the app before committing to a subscription.
Final Verdict
Both OnlyRecipe and Paprika are excellent recipe managers, but they serve different types of cooks in 2025.
Paprika is perfect if you want a reliable, one-time purchase app for saving recipes from traditional websites. It's been around for years, works great offline, and has all the essential features you need.
OnlyRecipe is the choice for modern cooks who discover recipes on TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram. Its AI-powered features—including social media imports, screenshot recognition, and handwritten recipe digitization—represent the future of recipe management.
If you're discovering recipes on social media in 2025, OnlyRecipe's AI features will save you hours of manual work. If you primarily use traditional recipe websites and prefer a one-time purchase, Paprika remains an excellent choice.
Ready to Try OnlyRecipe?
Start with our free plan—20 recipes and 3 AI imports per day. No credit card required.
